What R. Kelly’s conviction for the Chicago charges means
Monday’s verdict raises the obvious question: How does this ruling change or shape the landscape of its remaining cases?
“It’s a bit double”, says the Advocate General Phillip C. hamilton, Managing Partner at Hamilton-Clarke, LLP. “Chicago examines what Eastern District prosecutors have been able to do. You don’t often see someone being charged with running a criminal enterprise when it’s not like a Mafia or the MS-13. If they could get it across, it means that the sentiment towards R. Kelly that once existed when we heard the kind of activity happening but he was still doing his job in the industry, has clearly changed. Federal prosecutors in Chicago think “we can catch him, he’s no longer invincible.”
Kelly could also choose to plead instead of going to trial. “His attorneys in Chicago should start having more fruitful discussions about what a plea might look like,” Hamilton adds. “He might also think that if he eliminated one case with an appeal it would be New York and that he would want to go further in terms of fighting the federal Chicago case. He has all kinds of math, so everything is really there. It depends on what he wants to do with the case in New York. Does he want to appeal or use it in some way or another to take advantage of federal prosecutors in Chicago for can – be talking about a global deal? We’ll see. “
But chances of it winning on appeal are “fairly low” in federal court, criminal defense lawyer says Isabelle A. Kirshner, partner at Clayman & Rosenberg, LLP. “The likelihood of his case being overturned is minimal. The likelihood of him getting a life sentence is quite large, so he may be thinking, ‘why spend all that money on another trial and be dragged across the country to different prisons , so let me just finish it’s okay now and plead. ‘”
Alternatively, Kirshner adds, local jurisdictions in Illinois and Minnesota may choose to drop some or all of the state’s affairs, as Kelly already faces a lot of jail time and saving resources as these lawsuits. high profile can be expensive.
However, his federal case in Chicago is getting nowhere.
“All the time, money and resources that went into preparing this case for them just to say, ‘okay, you’re fine in New York, we’re not going to go ahead here’, I just think it’s unlikely, ”says Hamilton. . “In their minds, they think he should have dropped the state business in 2008, so they’ll want him now.”
The first allegations that R. Kelly used his fame to sexually abuse teenage girls surfaced decades ago, but it wasn’t until 2019 that the Chicago-born artist – who had previously been acquitted in a 2008 child pornography case – was taken to jail awaiting trial in Brooklyn. His sentence will now be determined by Judge Ann M. Donnelly on May 4, 2022.
The Chicago federal trial has been repeatedly postponed, and although a new date has not been set, the next conference hearing for this case is October 20. If all parties decide to go ahead with a trial, it could start before he is sentenced. in New York, says Hamilton.
“I don’t know if the Chicago judge would want to wait until June to start this,” he said. “I’m not saying it’s impossible, but if they’re going to move forward, I think there’s a chance it will start before May.”